NHL fans in Canada are up in arms after the Edmonton Oilers chose not to pursue goalie Carter Hart this week. Hart was labeled a “non‑starter” amidst controversy tied to the Hockey Canada Five case, despite acquittals in court. The NHL maintains a league-wide ban pending review.
The decision has ignited spirited debate: some argue that teams must uphold accountability, while others suggest Hart deserves a second chance. The Oilers’ stance may signal a broader shift in how front offices handle reputational concerns.
Edmonton’s fan base responded strongly, with social media threads demanding transparency and alternative player options. Executives face pressure to explain how character assessments factor into roster decisions.
Meanwhile, the NHL continues to review the broader case implications. League sources confirm evaluations of both personal conduct and public trust remain central to future reinstatements.
Hart’s status now hangs in the balance. Should the NHL lift its moratorium, the goalie may still find a spot—though this week’s decision has undoubtedly complicated his return.