In a heartfelt victory for Mariah Carey and her beloved holiday anthem, a federal judge in Los Angeles has ruled that the iconic singer did not steal her timeless hit, All I Want For Christmas Is You, from other songwriters. The decision, delivered by Judge Mónica Ramírez Almadani on Wednesday, brings an end to a $20 million lawsuit filed in 2023 by songwriters Andy Stone (known as Vince Vance) and Troy Powers, who claimed Carey’s 1994 holiday classic infringed on their 1989 country song of the same name.
The Lawsuit and Its Claims
Andy Stone and Troy Powers, the songwriters behind the 1989 country version of All I Want For Christmas Is You, alleged that Carey’s 1994 hit borrowed heavily from their work. Their song, which peaked at No. 31 on Billboard’s Hot Country chart, told a story of someone disillusioned with material gifts, longing only to be with their loved one and writing a letter to Santa Claus to express that heartfelt wish.
Stone and Powers argued that the “unique linguistic structure” of their song—combining themes of love, longing, and holiday tradition—was copied by Carey and her co-writer, Walter Afanasieff. They claimed there was an “overwhelming likelihood” that Carey had heard their version and used it as inspiration for her own.
The Judge’s Ruling
Judge Mónica Ramírez Almadani, however, saw no merit in the claims. After reviewing expert testimony from both sides, she ruled that the themes in both songs were common Christmas tropes that predated either version.
“The plaintiffs have not met the burden of showing that the songs are substantially similar,” Judge Ramírez Almadani stated in her ruling. She emphasized that Carey’s song used these elements in a distinct way, with its own melody, structure, and lyrical phrasing.
The judge also criticized the lawsuit as “frivolous,” stating that the plaintiffs’ attorneys had made “no reasonable effort to ensure that the factual contentions asserted have evidentiary support.” As a result, she ordered Stone, Powers, and their legal team to pay at least part of Carey and Afanasieff’s attorney fees.
A Song That Defines the Holidays
For Mariah Carey, this ruling is more than just a legal victory—it’s a validation of a song that has become a cherished part of holiday traditions worldwide. Since its release, All I Want For Christmas Is You has grown into a cultural juggernaut, topping Billboard’s Hot 100 chart for six consecutive years and becoming one of the best-selling singles of all time.
The song’s enduring popularity is a testament to its universal appeal. According to Billboard, Carey’s holiday hit has earned over $60 million in royalties and has been streamed billions of times globally. Its opening notes are synonymous with the holiday season, evoking feelings of love, joy, and nostalgia.
Reactions from Both Sides
In an email to The Associated Press, the plaintiffs’ attorney, Gerard P. Fox, expressed disappointment with the ruling. “We filed based on the opinions of two esteemed musicologists who teach at great colleges,” he said. “My client will make a decision shortly on whether to appeal.”
On the other side, Carey and her team have remained relatively quiet about the lawsuit. While neither Carey nor Afanasieff has publicly commented on the ruling, their victory speaks volumes. For Carey, the song is more than just a hit—it’s a piece of her legacy, a gift to the world that continues to spread holiday cheer.
A Legacy of Love and Joy
The lawsuit briefly brought Carey and Afanasieff together as allies, despite their own past disagreements over the song’s creation. While they’ve publicly debated who contributed what to the hit, this case reminded them of the legacy they built together—a legacy that continues to bring joy to millions every year.
As the song’s opening notes play each year, they remind us that sometimes, all we really want for Christmas is love—and maybe a little Mariah Carey magic.
Closing Thoughts
Judge Ramírez Almadani’s ruling not only protects Carey’s iconic song but also reaffirms its place in holiday history. For fans around the world, All I Want For Christmas Is You is more than just a melody—it’s a reminder of the joy, love, and togetherness that define the season.
As Carey herself might say, this ruling is the perfect gift—a victory for creativity, a celebration of music, and a testament to the enduring power of a song that continues to warm hearts year after year.
️
